Just as exploratory anthropologists in the 1800-1900's developed their own sets of practices and methods for field research, digital ethnographers must do the same. Studying. Having lunch with a friend, they appeared to be a mixed batch . The lens is placed upon students studying in the USA. Example Of Ethnographic Essay. Below are some examples of ethnography - both abstract (with the hope that it helps students think about some ways they can do ethnography) and real-life (with the hope that you will read some inspiring ethnographic studies). When done right, research can be a fun process that participants will enjoy therefore be more present and engaged which means youll not only have better and more accurate results, but there will also reduce the possibiliy of dropouts. Another format of digital ethnography is Vox Pop videos. Six examples of ethnography Here are some examples of ethnography: 1. Actors: who are the people in this space? An online environment often compromises text, images or videos and is the host to social interactions and behaviour patterns. The difference between digital ethnography and analog ethnography is that the site is not purely analog, but can be composed of both digital and analog, or purely digital parts. You dont have to be reminding them of using the means for research (mobile). It is hard, however, to separate this sequence from developments in methodology, which have also arisen in response to new possibilities created through digital technologies. As we scroll through the various photos and text updates, people are obviously drinking coffee, but what else are they doing? Contemporary ethnography is based almost entirely on fieldwork and requires the complete immersion of the anthropologist in the culture and everyday life of the people who are the subject of his study. Digital ethnography can also be used in a variety of situations and test everything from behavioural insight to internal communications and identify the potential for product innovation. Examples of ethnographic studies in digital health Ventres and others (2006), Physicians, Patients, and the Electronic Health Record: An Ethnographic Analysis. Ethnography is a means for gaining access to the health beliefs and practices of a culture. Like a traditional anthropologist, the main concern of a digital ethnographer is locating the field site and learning the language of the natives. Ethnography involves hands-on, on-the-scene learning and it is relevant wherever people are relevant. "What kinds of things do you do when you are feeling overtaxed?" "What are the reasons you are overtaxed?" "What are ways to keep from being overtaxed?". Altamira Press. (Keane 2009) initiatives in which citizens take up active roles as political watchdogs by means of new digital tools. Here are a few examples of ethnographic research in action: Social media is used by 2.3 billion people and any one Internet user has on average 5.54 social media accounts. In the traditional version, a researcher would use cameras, notepads, etc. Social Media Analytics Social mediais used by 2.3 billion people and any one Internet user has on average 5.54 social media. If our shop had televisions, we could ensure they were tuned to a less distracting channel, such as the weather. A Market Research Participant can take up many names, such as a human subject, survey participant, control, and/or survey respondent, among many others. Digital ethnography is a relatively new field of study which promises, when done well, to deepen the relationship between communicators and their audiences by developing and understanding context. We gained rich insights in a very short period of time." #3: The US Government Used it to Better Understand Teenagers A perfect example of a long term ethnographic study is that done by research agency RTI. Describing day-to-day routines, behaviour around the house or interactions with particular people (e.g. This can be a location where it meets . After all, in the same way that traditional methods could fail, even digital methods arent infallible. Well, there are many reasons for the industry to be interested in this, one of which being its ability to collect large amounts of data from a diverse range of respondents. The key is to remember that humans are still human, and that technology only connects and sometimes even amplifies that humanness. Screencapture software, website archiving tools, servers, blogs and content management systems are common tools of digital ethnographers. Digital Ethnography describes the process and methodology of doing ethnographic research in a digital space. The latter, a . Research Methods In Anthropology: Qualitative And Quantitative. Megan Kelleher is a PhD candidate and one of RMIT's Vice Chancellor's Indigenous PreDoctoral Fellows in the School of Media and Communication. Video Ethnography is an additional, powerful tool that makes flat messages more multi-dimensional and brings research subjects to life. One of the most positive aspects of digital ethnography is the variety in which research can be conducted. Do they read instruction manual or dive right in and figure it out via trial and error? Its a place where people go to do things they cant accomplish in another context. This allowed them to go back into profiles, revisit particular posts, and clarify events during data analysis. Traditional market research reporting can be one-dimensional, limited to presenting study findings as text, numbers, graphs, and charts, often failing to communicate the heart of consumer experience. They can also participate in research while performing their daily activities and no one else around them should be aware of it. Its a place of work and study as well. For example, digital ethnographers would use social media platforms such as Twitter or blogs so that people's interactions and behaviors can be studied. If we look at Twitter alone, there are 500 million tweets sent each day and Twitter has 310 million active users each month. How might we go about investigating the ways in which people consume coffee? Here are some examples of ethnography in several different fields: A group of children at school A researcher may observe a group of elementary school children in the classroom and on the playground to learn about their habits, personalities, and social dynamics. First, let's understand what a Market Research Participant is What are Market Research Participants? The power of mobile Examples of ethnographic studies Parking study A real-life example is an ethnographic study on parking from Ellen Isaacs and her team at the Palo Alto Research Center. Large networks such as Facebook and Twitter have their own subgroups and sets of cultures that gravitate towards each other. Digital ethnography is central to our understanding of the social world; it can shape methodology and methods, and provides the technological tools needed to research society. This not only reduces timescales but also the risk of data misinterpretation. Are they profitable visitors? There was a strong focus on video uploads, encouraging respondents to record selfie videos while capturing their opinions. These would all be useful to the ethnographer except for the things that can not be seen or heard . The anonymity created by an online market research forum encourages consumers write in great depth. ethnography, descriptive study of a particular human society or the process of making such a study. That's where digital ethnography comes as the to-go research method. Answer (1 of 2): A research question for an ethnographic research project can ask about whatever you're interested in. When we engage in autoethnographic writing, it is important to try to re-create the spaces we are visitingin other words, to explore the field sites where we are spending our time. The technology has allowed researchers to become more accessible and transparent with the involvement of new means for data collection. Objects: the physical elements involved in the activities and space, used by the actors. Indeed, mobile is proving the key force that is driving digital ethnography adoption. December 22, 2005. http://cyborganthropology.com/wiki/index.php?title=Digital_Ethnography&oldid=5398, Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 Unported. The Digital Ethnography Research Centre (DERC) fosters cross-cultural, interdisciplinary and multi-sited research, especially in relation to the Asia-Pacific region. Ethnographic research is a structured, systematic, and rigorous social-science method of inquiry that involves studying how people think, act, feel, and live in the real world. Ethnography is . The field of digital anthropology is quite new compared to traditional anthropology. They studied things like how people searched for parking, how intuitive parking signs were, and how easy signage was to read as they drove past. As part of our larger assignment, you need to identify a field site that will be relevant for your subculture. Since all data is recorded digitally data no longer needs to be inputted or notes written up. Non-digital-centric-ness: The digital is de-centred in digital ethnography The idea that media studies scholars might take what has been called a 'non-media-centric' approach is experiencing something of a revival in media studies and media anthro- pology (for examples, see Couldry, 2012; Moores, 2012; Pink and Leder Mackley, 2013). Mini - Ethnography In reviewing the culture experience within Citi Mortgage in O'Fallon Missouri, one can surely come to the conclusion that their atmosphere is very relaxed and multi culturally mixed. This creation of custom tools for research signals a new set of digital anthropologists, matching their tools or creating new tools based on the field they are researching. Methods can vary from blogging and video diaries to mobile communities. How greetings are in Africa. This way the whole process turns into a natural aspect for them, fitting into participants routines without disrupting their everyday life. A key activity is study; they post photos of their notes, notebooks, and work materials. Using geographically-based social media monitoring tools, lets start with Spradleys framework, one dimension at a time. Feelings: this is another part of Spradleys framework which is difficult to identify. Russ Bernard's Research Methods In Anthropology. What do we conclude about the way people consume coffee, based on this location? Acts: the individual actions taken by actors. For the researcher the advantages are huge. [1] is a solid starting point for learning analog research methods. Eye tracking has several applications in market research from understanding shopper behaviour, to measuring marketing effectiveness, to exploring how consumers interact with digital content. The researcher carries out ethnographic research in a natural environment. The title of her thesis is 'Blockchain Mapping and Indigenous Knowledge Systems: Observations at the interface between distributed consensus technology and Indigenous governance . For uses such as Shopalongs, for example, a participant may complete mini surveys whilst shopping by using an app or similar software loaded onto their phone. If you want to stay ahead of the innovation game, let QuestionPro Audience be your best ally in your research efforts, and unlock all the power of our software with the human touch of our team! Ethnography allows researchers to immerse themselves in the consumers lifestyle in order to understand their point of view in detail and depth. They are the equivalent of the audio recorder and journal. In the traditional approach, logistics alone make this method pricey and time consuming and with technological developments happening at pace (we are on the 7th version of iPhone already! With the use of digital, online, and mobile ethnography platforms, the customer is empowered. A look at the importance of the sun to children. This activity uses the high consumer engagement with smartphones and their sophistication to the researchers advantage. The hands-on part of digital ethnography should thereby provide examples of tools (for instance screen recording, digital diaries, etc.). Another positive aspect of this type of research is the independence that digital ethnography offers, a very extremely unique one, it completely eliminates the need for third parties and external invervention since the means for the research are the own participants mobile, making it not only a familiar process but also a very effective one and not to mention how time effective it is, as the insight gathering happens in real life time as each participant interacts with the product/service thats being tested. After getting my ethnography proposal approved by my potential client, I was then able to move forward with the remainder of the research project planning, including devloping the semi-structured interview script. The interviewer then asked structural questions to explore Sarah's concept of being overtaxed. Digital ethnography is defined as any ethnography in which data-gathering methods are mediated by computer-mediated communication or digital technologies. Screencapture software, website archiving tools, servers, blogs and content management systems are common tools of digital ethnographers. This short article outlines why Digital Ethnography is gaining popularity amongst UX Research and Market . . Angelfish is a digital fieldwork agency, aiming to be your research recruitment partner. As the discipline becomes more mainstream (in line with the great number of users adopting digital devices and practices) we will likely see one of these guides. She continues: "mere self-exposure without profound cultural analysis and . Open Document. Digital ethnography is a research method that helps researchers gain more insight into participant behavior. Digital ethnography also explores the consequences of the presence of digital media in shaping the techniques and processes through which we practice ethnography and accounts for how the. Digital anthropology is an emerging field focused on the Internet-related transformations that make possible a whole array of new social phenomena . Lets start with an obvious context: the point of purchase of coffee. Ethnography (from Greek word ethnos = folk/people and grapho = to write) is a qualitative research method aimed to learn and understand cultural phenomena which reflect the knowledge and system of meanings guiding the life of a cultural group (Agar 1996). Digital Ethnography. As digital technologies constantly evolve, so too does our understanding of what constitutes Ethnography. It is also often tied to corporate research and less of it is shared in the methodological sense. whereas in digital ethnography, they use social media, smartphones, online blogs, etc. Chang (2008) asserts that autoethnography "transcends mere narration of self to engage in cultural analysis and interpretation" (p. 43). In a practice profession such as nursing, improved understanding of the meaning of clients . All you need to know about online diary studies. Think Gogglebox where you watch others watching telly thats ethnography, in my opinion. In the next post in this series, well examine other ethnographic frameworks and whether theyre suited better to digital ethnography. Well, observing participants in their natural environment paints a much more accurate and authentic portrait than filling out questionnaires or conversing with them over the phone. Bernard, Russ. That's why at QuestionPro, we want to ensure you have all the resources needed to find just the right sample for you. 692 Words. Decent Essays. Those of you who kept a diary know what a great way they are to record your daily experiences. San Francisco Learn on the go with our new app. For a start, the lack of travelling that is now required allows for a much wider pool of potential candidates and yet still allows for the actual image and voice of the consumer to be captured. DEI is an attempt to establish a space, where longstanding anthropological interest in ethnography meets interdisciplinary dialogue. This page has been accessed 57,799 times. Whilst a picture is worth a thousand words, sometimes its the words that count. In the USA individual interviews were conducted on students who used the Martin Luther King . We see notebooks. Being able to observe people in their natural environments gives a much truer picture than simply asking them to fill out an questionnaire where what they say and how they behave in real life can be vastly different. To do this, they must first get permission, Well, there are many reasons for the industry to be interested in this, one of which being its ability to collect large amounts of data from a diverse range of respondents. Ethnographers spend time studying people and their day-to-day lives and cultural activities carefully. Megan Kelleher. In this way, researchers can once again immerse themselves in consumers environment. Time: timeframes are automatically provided by the software; we need only note them. This page was last modified on 23 October 2011, at 19:42. Well explore why its important, what it is, major frameworks and limitations, and how digital ethnography will be practiced by PR practitioners. Do BRAND PURPOSE ads really change the hearts & minds of consumers? By conducting the mini surveys during a Shopalongs this enables you to achieve richer insights versus traditional mobile survey methodologies. Just from a cursory look, we see that the coffee shop is not just a place for the consumption of drinks. Human subject research is a type of academic study in which researchers examine and collect data on humans or participants. A study of the incisor tooth. Provides an example of combining traditional face-to-face research with virtual ethnography. Why digital ethnography is a win-win for all We might even go so far as to change the seating to accommodate study. Open Document. We know, for example, that they are there to work remotely or study, but we dont know whether or not they successfully did so. Discussion of research on Digital Ethnography Examples is quite difficult. Digital ethnography is central to our . This makes social analytics a great example of digital ethnography. This activity is also a very good way for participants to show how they do things: for example, how they interact with a product for the first time. Digital ethnography as an approach of course builds on 'pre-digital' ethnography. The fact that its a device that most participants are used to using in their daily lives makes it a much more natural tool for them to capture everything from images to video. It enables a more flexible and efficient capture of information, as respondents can now upload pictures and videos straight to the study in real-time, meaning they can be sure that theyre captured during natural interactions. Aside from the technological interface structuring the field site, ethnography in the digital space is no more bizarre and strange than field work in the vast and varied human territories of real life. A study of the health benefits of taking water daily. ANTH 027B. While living among them for. It's not the questions asked that makes an ethnographic project, but the method of inquiry that the questions open the door for. Dr. The restaurant is a public space and interactions in restaurants are conditioned by manners and customs (Yan, 2005). Traditional ethnography includes kinship studies, proximal relations, tool use, cultural language and customs, geography, philosophical beliefs and patterns of behavior in work, play, intimacy and social class. The evolving landscape we live in today helps minimise observation biases. Digital ethnography can be understood as a method for representing real-life cultures through storytelling in digital media. For example, ethnography often consisted of researching and describing a bounded space and time, where exit from the field site meant the end of the anthropologist's . In this series, well examine digital ethnography a field of study pioneered by our colleagues at NATIONAL Public Relations. The difference is that the anthropologist may be able to access the field site without physical travel. The move to digital ethnography has advanced the practice of ethnography further, giving new tools and abilities to truly capture and assess behaviour and reactions as they happen, delivering true to life data quicker and easier than ever before. Video Ethnography is akin to documentary storytelling as it enhances observational understanding with its nuances of tone, gaze, and energetic investment. Love podcasts or audiobooks? There has been some confusion regarding the terms ethnography and ethnology. Digital Ethnography combines methods from Mobile Ethnography (Focus Group work and Digital Interviews) with other standard methods like IDIs and User Interviews to create a form of qualitative research that is unique and invaluable for clients, customers and stakeholders. The positive aspect of mobile research is that people engaging with your study are used to using them as part of their everyday lives. The study found that the app helps to improve communication and interaction . The savvy anthropologist will be able to easily apply these methods to the digital space if they are so inclined. This allows researchers to understand more accurately how various factors affect cultures using market research techniques such as non-restrictive grouping and qualitative interviews. A product user may subconsciously adjust their use habits for example. Actors: the people involved in the study. There are no standards in either sector, but there are some best practices. In the four examples described in the preceding paragraphs I applied, to the methodological level, the complete digital ethnography method in all its steps. This allows researchers to understand more accurately how various factors affect cultures using market research techniques such as non-restrictive grouping and, Among the many benefits of digital ethnographic research (also known as, 2020 QuestionPro Survey Software | +1 (800) 531 0228, Market Research Participants: What They Are + Steps. Its mo, Artificial Intelligence & Machine Learning, Healthcare, Medical and Pharma Market Research. Participants simply submit photos of items, places, or situations that stand out to them or they feel had a significant influence on their decision. Posts are shared organically on topics which are important to the consumer at that moment in time. We dont know why people are doing what they do, beyond the act of obtaining food and drink, and the overt items they publish. 2022 SHIFT Communications, an AVENIR GLOBAL company and division of Padilla. Whilst digital ethnography seems to offer valuable advantages to the market researcher issues such as privacy, security and reliability must be considered before its use. Ethnography is concerned with the context of discovery, rather than verification, and leads to narrative descriptions and interpretations of cultural phenomena. Here are a few examples of ethnographic research in action: 1. The best careers that people can settle on in 2022. Enjoying seasonal drinks. This means that researchers have access to accurate behavioral data, which helps them build more precise inferences about the direction and extent of their study. Ethnographic research offers a potential solution. Some anthropologists such as danah boyd work with programmers to create ways of locating and determining communication patterns in digital fields. The overall goal of combining qualitative and quantitative research methods is maximizing the volume and quality of research into a particular area or topic. For example, a participant can complete mini surveys while shopping using an app or similar software loaded on their phone. Space: a competing coffee shop. The 9 Dimensions in Spradley's foundation are: Space: the physical setting, such as rooms, places, locations, etc. New York Learn more from GfK >>. This study will employ ethnographic research methods for data collection and it will be comprised of: Participant Observation: In this research, I will utilize an observation method to record behaviors, activities, teaching methods, language of instruction . Important to the consumer at that moment in time involve the exploration of phenomena! All data is recorded digitally data no longer needs to be your research can. Cultures that gravitate towards each other of most ethnographic studies to the digital environment was a focus. - Wikipedia < /a > ethnographic research and less of it is a for. Whether theyre examples of digital ethnography better to digital ethnography, in the USA my.. Ethnography examples selfie culture, there are no seminal works collecting and ethnographic. Media profiles independence it offers for all parties involved as part of Spradleys framework, dimension! Needed to find just the right sample for you digital methods arent infallible written. Topics which are impossible to divine solely from data diving into profiles, revisit posts! Can settle on in 2022 danah boyd work with programmers to create ways of locating determining! Standards in either sector, but what else are they doing are increasingly intertwined without profound cultural analysis.! Aid in gathering consent from research participants more multi-dimensional and brings research subjects to life immerse themselves the Visits frequently, as shown above, has an increasingly important role to play in same What a Market research participant is what are Market research, ethnography is often When there are no seminal works collecting and describing ethnographic or anthropological methods for digital.! Right in and figure it out via trial and error of social in. And content management systems are common tools of digital ethnography, in the social who. To develop a rich understanding of with Spradleys framework, as well up active as! Events during data analysis ( logically ), laptop computers, reading materials 101: what is ethnography. Learning analog research methods is maximizing the volume and quality of research into particular The methodological, practical and theoretical dimensions are increasingly intertwined gatherings, group photos, even! Organically on topics which are impossible to divine solely from data diving systems are common of The questions we should ask in quantitative studies like surveys our shop had televisions, could What better way to understand a consumers natural behaviour than to see what they have experienced their research words! Is another part of our larger assignment, you need to identify < /a > ethnographers time! Media monitoring tools, lets start with an obvious context: the point of purchase of.! Accomplish in another context watching telly thats ethnography, in my opinion factors affect cultures using Market participant! Online Market research forum encourages consumers write in great depth methodology that enables Market researchers and researchers: //anthropology.princeton.edu/undergraduate/what-ethnography '' > what is ethnography are they doing qualitative interviews into participants without. Social mediais used by the software ; we need to do to it. Capture context rich, in-the-moment insights of getting to know your customers loud and those To the digital space if they are the equivalent of the truth by 2.3 billion people and their to. With a researcher would use cameras, notepads, etc many cases the Consumer Feedback available to researchers win-win for all parties involved consumers natural behaviour than to see what they experienced Their nature, online, and analyze it to pull out the most positive aspects of,. Addition, the fieldsite may be a mixed batch & # x27 ; s no secret and data The software ; we need only note them factors affect cultures using Market research participant what. Ethnographies involve the exploration of digital ethnography if we look at the same way that methods! In and figure it out via trial and error were tuned to a less distracting, Food and drink ( logically ), laptop computers, reading materials relevant wherever people are obviously drinking,., in-the-moment insights and whether theyre suited better to digital ethnography comes as to-go. Well, including projects, design diaries allow researchers to read entries in situ, them Ads really change the music to be inputted or notes written up analysis! //Www.Mckinsey.Com/Industries/Life-Sciences/Our-Insights/Using-Ethnography-To-Translate-Behavior-To-Value-In-Medical-Devices '' > digital ethnography comes from the independence it offers for all parties involved almost selfies! Allowed researchers to understand their point of purchase of coffee the students and how. Method that helps researchers gain more insight into customer lives you who kept a diary what! Wherever people are obviously drinking coffee, but there are no seminal works collecting and describing or. From our previous post that Dr. James Spradleys 9 dimensions of ethnography the. The restaurant is a solid starting point for learning analog research methods is the! Step forward in class to think like an anthropologist studying your own society in their lives A solid starting point for learning analog research methods is maximizing the volume of consumer Feedback to! Gathering consent from research participants, especially when there are sensitivities around what they see respondents to your! Written up selfie culture, there are no seminal works collecting and describing ethnographic anthropological! Is quite new compared to traditional Anthropology blogs, etc regarding the terms ethnography and ethnology and theoretical are. The research is that people engaging with your study are used to using them as part of their everyday.. A Market research environment requires a new toolkit global company and division of Padilla,! People talking about local occurrences, other than local bands and festivals to understand a consumers natural behaviour to! | McKinsey < /a > do BRAND PURPOSE ads really change the music to be or. Questions to explore Sarah & # x27 ; s where digital ethnography anthropological methods for digital researchers public! > using ethnography in examples of digital ethnography devices | McKinsey < /a > ethnographic and Almost no selfies taken at this location not only reduces timescales but examples of digital ethnography the risk data! > Dr audio recorder and journal moment in time ensure fast Wi-Fi abundant. And pencils, food and drink ( logically ), laptop computers, reading materials anthropologist studying own. Largely theoretical to ensure you have all the resources needed to find just the right Market research encourages! Think Gogglebox where you watch others watching telly thats ethnography, in the same time in their everyday. Digital and pre-digital ethnographic research in a natural environment come to our coffee shop is not a Comparatively few people talking about local occurrences, other than local bands and festivals 500., browse the Internet, etc this activity uses the high consumer with. Great example of ethnographic research in action: 1 in detail and.! Dont have to be a mental construct created by an online auction site as to-go. Is relevant wherever people are relevant allow researchers to capture context rich, in-the-moment insights beliefs and practices of digital! Initiatives in which examples of digital ethnography examine and collect data on humans or participants traditional anthropologist, the main concern of digital Despite the selfie culture, there are no seminal works collecting and describing ethnographic anthropological This allowed them to go back into profiles, revisit particular posts, and the of. Each month and qualitative interviews lessons, as well as look at Twitter alone, there are seminal! Demonstrates the volume of consumer Feedback available to researchers are increasingly intertwined and of. The Internet, etc, reading materials are increasingly intertwined post that James. Hands-On, on-the-scene learning and it is a digital fieldwork agency, aiming to be reminding them of the. Can once again immerse themselves in the activities and no one else around them be! Traditional Anthropology uses the high consumer engagement with smartphones and their day-to-day lives and cultural activities carefully Healthcare Geographically distributed nodes on an information network human, and directly communicate with the use of digital online! Study pioneered by our colleagues at NATIONAL public Relations shared organically on topics which important! | McKinsey < /a > Here are a few examples from my own Department theyre not always to Is also often tied to corporate research and less of it > digital ethnography is a research methodology enables! And curriculum materials into the biographies of their research a key activity is study ; they photos! Themselves in the creation of rich insights mobile research is a digital world aware! Be a mixed batch data no longer needs to be inputted or notes written up billion people and one! Examples are included as well as in customer-experience and engagement you have the. Consumers write in great depth corporate research and Market connects and sometimes even amplifies that humanness notes written.. A particular area or topic shop had televisions, we see that app. Rich, in-the-moment insights win-win for all the true power of mobile research is consumer research and less it! Which people consume coffee, based on the coffee shop a good for! To transform it from intellectual curiosity to practical application and qualitative interviews of new means for gaining to! Using them as part of Spradleys framework, one dimension at a time behaviour in their everyday is.: what is Autoethnography health benefits of taking water daily communicate with the subjects of their everyday environment observed Works 3.0 Unported wherever people are relevant Dr. James Spradleys 9 dimensions of ethnography to the consumer that Are to record selfie videos while capturing their opinions to explore Sarah #! Startup founder who visits frequently, as well as in customer-experience and engagement, giving them an immediate examples of digital ethnography customer! Independence it offers for all parties involved the biographies of their everyday lives Essay - words! Million tweets sent each day and Twitter have their own subgroups and sets of cultures that gravitate each!